I too appreciate the conversations and I thank you for your patience with the questions. It sounds like you were wise to suppress your initial feelings. You gave yourself time to "evolve" as you put it.You’re very welcomed and thank you for the honest questions. I appreciate the conversation we have been having and I have been trying to answer you as honestly as I can.
I did eventually share my feelings with my wife regarding what it felt like to see her with other men. But when I did it was more along the lines of explaining why seeing her with others was a turn on and to share how over time, I evolved personally.
To give some context I would consider myself personality wise an Alpha, clean cut conservative type, not much in to role play especially anything DOM/SUB related (have experimented). An open relationship in my early years would definitely not have been something I would consider.
I can’t say if sharing my apprehension early on would have made a difference. I think it may have because the wife may have not opened up if she thought I was conflicted or it was a negative experience. My attitude was I suppose in line with how most of us (men) keep things bottled up. To an extent I did not say anything because I had already told her I was good with it and did not want to back out/down. I have to give this some more thought but I would say it is better to keep your thoughts to yourself, at least initially because they don’t really serve of purpose to share them. I was not ready to pull the plug after our first experience but would say that if you have overwhelming negative feelings you should put a stop to it.
I should mention that the “conflict” felt in my opinion is pretty normal. It is one of those things that on the one hand your wife is having sex with another man and this is taboo. Then on the other hand my wife is having sex with another man and this is such a turn on.
To add on to what you said as far as that you, “believe that you need to have your own head together” I think you are 100% correct, this is very much a mental challenge. Confidence, ego, jealousy, possessiveness are all things/emotions in our heads. It is something we have to deal with before going forward.
I think I mentioned going slow when thinking of having an open relationship and how to know how you will REALLY react. Something I heard once was to share a pic or pics of your wife with another man and then see how his reaction to her makes you feel. It is sort of superficial but it is a start. I did not try this myself but it would seem one way to “test the waters” of your own emotional reactions.
It also sounds like you've survived and moved on personally. How do you guys do your "hot wifing"? What is your own personal sex life like? Is it better than ever?