“She” has me going at first. But when I read the episode which involved sex for the first time, I knew we’d been had. I’ve never known a woman to actually talk like that (typos aside). It had all the stereotypical stuff we guys fantasize about (bigger dick, 1st orgasm, etc) and ridiculous explicit language. It was basically pandering, and it was blatantly obvious.
The whole amusement park ride episode was a major stretch too.
I think we want so badly for these stories to be real and true that we often overlook certain red flags. For the rare few of us within the general population that have actually done anything remotely resembling wife sharing or cuckoldry, we want to connect with similar people. For those who feel it may never be more than a fantasy, they want to experience it through others.