Yeah man reading your last two posts, you're not in a good spot. You're clearly grasping. Like checking her panties. Unless you're going to send it to a lab it's pretty much useless. You can be the #1 expert in identifying jizz vs female discharge on panties and all she has to say is that you're crazy, that's clearly female discharge.
any ideas guys / girls apart from divorce court
Buddy, there's no trick out there that will fix this. From what you're saying things are really bad. It really does sound like she's cheating. She can start being very blatant about it and will still deny. The #1 rule among in the cheating community is "Deny, deny, deny". I'm not joking they litterally say that to people freaked out because they were discovered. Do you remember that song by Shaggy "It Wasn't me" years ago? Read the lyrics, that's exactly what they do. Even if you can manage to drag them to marriage counseling it won't even matter. They will only say what you want to hear and continue cheating. Divorce needs to be something you consider and ironically heading down the path of divorce might be what it takes for her to realize you're serious and she needs to work on your relationship thus saving the marriage.
You really need to talk to a lawyer for a consultation. It won't cost much if anything. It will outline what your divorce might look like and may provide you with new information or ideas on things you can do to help your possition in a divorce. If SHTF and she decides to nuke the marriage you'll be in a far better position if you already had visited a lawyer. A consultation with a lawyer isn't committing to anything. You're holding off because psychologically you feel that it is committing. But you REALLY need to for 1 really important reason. You're absolutely lost right now. You don't see anything you can do and it makes you feel powerless. You need a plan. You need to take action. A lawyer consultation is you taking action. It will be you taking back power. The lawyer will be able to help you come up with a brief plan, mostly from a legal standpoint, of what to do if things go bad.
If you're worried about the cuckold part of the situation, just don't mention it. Say it's a swinger or open marriage thing with rules and she's breaking all of them. The details that separate cuckolding from swinging and open marriage don't matter here and after you consider that saying this is a swinging or open marriage thing where she's breaking the set rules is pretty much true.
This probably isn't the best place for this. Check out r/cheatingstories on reddit and post your situation. You will get a lot of great suggestions.
Yes it does make perfect sense why this is an issue even though you're open to her ...... around. Do you know what's probably the most popular phrase you hear when someone talks about getting cheated on? "It's not so much the sex. I can probably get over that. It's the lying." That's exactly the issue here. There's the obvious loss of trust which itself kills marriages. As unconventional you think your situation is the thing that's killing it is the same thing that kills a marriage with a completely vanilla couple where one has a drunken one night stand. Loss of trust.
But there's more to it. You have NO idea who she is messing around with. If you were in the loop and she told you then at the very least you would know who she is ...... with . If she plans on having sex with you again she would be putting your health at risk since one of the faceless men she's sneaking around with could have an STD. This should ******** you off. IF you make it through all of this at the very least she should suffer the humilation of getting screened for STDs before you ...... with her again.
I cannot say this enough, you need to talk to a lawyer. It almost sounds like you're so helpless you're praying that she will just fess up. I hate to tell you this but she won't. You can cry real tears and beg and she will still take the truth to the grave. Also if she is indeed involved with another man she may be experiencing limerence and deep in an affair fog. And if this is the case she's not going to do anything to help you. However it's not uncommon for cheaters to immediately get yanked out of the affair fog the very instant they realize their spouse is seriously considering divorce enough that they went to see a divorce lawyer. Mind you this isn't your prime reason to see a lawyer only a possible benefit.
If it helps I think I might have a theory of part of what she's doing. Some women don't really understand cuckolding. Consider how few couples there are that's actually in an open relationship and many of these relationships end up completely failing. This is because the couple really didn't understand open relationships and or overestimated their ability to handle it. Take that and add all the wild stuff that comes with cuckolding and even fewer couples would really understand it. There's something deeply rooted in many women that makes them immediately lose respect for a guy that's willing to share her. This isn't in the kinky fetish way but in the very real stop giving a crap about you and divorce you and move on way. If this is the case there's no telling how much of an effect it has on her choosing to do what she's doing. It could be huge or it could be small but just enough to push her to start fooling around and using the fact you get off on her cheating for her to justify her doing it.
Not trying to get too personal and this is more for you to think of than to actually give an answer to. How long have you two been together? (if a long time there's a higher chance she will eventually snap out of it) Who earns more? (gives an idea what divorce might look like) How old are you two?(same as the first question. If you're older and you want to have someone to "grow old with" then she's far more likely to eventually snap out of it) If things went sour and divorced happened who would move out if one of you actually does. (Some legal situations could arrise if one of you kicks the other out) Do you have options if you're the one that needs to move out? (Being prepared) Do you own your home or rent? (if you rent the split can happen much smoother. if you own you might need to think of financials. also if you own but only one of you are on the deed it's going to suck for the other if you split)
180 and grey rock still apply. These are for you and to help you cope just as much as it is for her to pull her back to reality. Maybe find yourself an individual counselor if it's possible to help you stop feeling like you're watching your life slowly disintergrate and you're powerless to stop it. But most importantly, go to a lawyer.
Also sorry I wish I checked back sooner. How are things going now?